Skip to Content

Oregon, 6 other states sue Trump administration over abortion, health care access


Claims rule aims 'to trick women into not paying their insurance premiums'

SALEM, Ore. (KTVZ) -- Oregon Attorney General Ellen Rosenblum joined a coalition of seven states and the District of Columbia on Thursday in suing the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services over a requirement that she said threatens women’s access to abortion and puts Oregon women at risk of accidentally losing health insurance coverage.

Last month, HHS issued a final rule that requires qualified health plans participating in the state exchanges to send two separate bills and to collect two separate payments if they offer abortion coverage.

Insurers would be required to separately bill for the portion of health insurance premiums attributable to abortion coverage, and then require women to make a separate payment of at least one dollar.

“I want to be very clear: This new rule is both confusing and unnecessary, and it is yet another attack on the right to a safe abortion,” Rosenblum said. “It is designed to discourage insurers from covering abortion services, and to trick women into not paying their insurance premiums, potentially causing their insurance coverage to be revoked because they did not pay a separate one-dollar bill.”

The lawsuit alleges that the new rule is incompatible with the ACA’s requirement of equitable access to healthcare and disproportionately affects states that are committed to ensuring comprehensive reproductive healthcare.

In the lawsuit, the coalition argues that the rule is unlawful because it:

  • Imposes onerous and unnecessary regulatory barriers aimed at restricting women’s constitutionally protected right to access abortion care;
  • Seeks to frustrate state sovereignty by coercing states to change their policies relating to the protection of abortion care;
  • Violates Section 1554 of the ACA, which prohibits the promulgation of any regulation that creates unreasonable barriers to the ability of individuals to obtain appropriate medical care; and
  • Exceeds HHS’s statutory authority under Section 1303 of the ACA.

“Oregonians have voted time and time again to support women’s reproductive health freedoms, and we won’t back down now over an arbitrary rule by the federal government to make it harder to access a safe and legal abortion,” Rosenblum said.

In addition to Oregon, the other states joining this coalition include California, New York, Maine, Maryland, Oregon, Vermont and the District of Columbia.

A copy of the lawsuit can be found here.

KTVZ news sources



  1. Pay for your own abortions. And how many abortions is one going to have to have “insurance” for abortions? One a year like a check up? 2 a year?

  2. ACA is nothing but a shell . . . gutted by Trump! As long as Trump is YOUR President, get used to it and get used to being told “NO”! Add to that, the number of Conservative Judges Trump has put in office and the latest SCOTUS ruling, you won’t have many activist judges to fall back on as well.

Leave a Reply

Skip to content