Skip to Content

Government pandemic watchdog warns of ‘reduced oversight’ for pandemic relief programs

The Treasury Department's special inspector general for pandemic recovery, Brian D. Miller, warns of 'reduced oversight' for pandemic relief programs
Alex Wong/Getty Images/CNN
The Treasury Department's special inspector general for pandemic recovery, Brian D. Miller, warns of 'reduced oversight' for pandemic relief programs

The Treasury Department’s special inspector general for pandemic recovery is warning of “reduced oversight” of two Covid relief programs given billions to distribute, as it says its jurisdiction has been hampered and claims “things are not working well.”

In a quarterly report to Congress released Friday, Brian Miller, the special inspector general, said his office and the Treasury inspector general were engaged in a months-long internal struggle concerning oversight of the airline industry’s Payroll Support Program and the Coronavirus Relief Fund for state and local governments.

The feud between the two inspectors general illustrates the challenges in tracking and preventing fraud in trillions of dollars in relief funds, and comes as the White House is pushing for trillions more in spending as part of its ambitious economic agenda following President Joe Biden’s signing of a $1.9 trillion Covid-19 economic relief package in March.

In his report, Miller said the Treasury Office of General Counsel and the Treasury inspector general did not feel his office had the authority to oversee the two pandemic relief programs, and so denied access to “mission-critical” data and declined to partner with Miller’s office.

Miller sought a final determination in January on his office’s jurisdiction from the Department of Justice’s Office of Legal Counsel. The OLC issued an opinion Thursday that the Treasury’s direct loans and the Federal Reserve’s lending programs fall under the purview of Miller’s office, but the Coronavirus Relief Fund, Payroll Support Program, and Paycheck Protection Program do not.

“The consequence is permanently reduced oversight of these programs,” Miller wrote of the OLC opinion.

CNN has reached out to the White House for comment.

“Treasury supports strong oversight and we will continue to make sure all of our Inspectors General congressional committees of judication and other oversight bodies have the information they need,” a Treasury spokesperson said in a statement.

A Treasury official told CNN that the department’s programs under the CARES Act are “all subject to oversight by multiple, overlapping oversight bodies.”

Miller’s report also contained a letter from Treasury’s principal deputy general counsel stating that Treasury hoped the two inspectors general offices could “resolve their disagreement” and that the department would abide by the OLC’s opinion on scope of jurisdiction.

“Treasury is dedicated to the prevention of waste, fraud and abuse, and we are committed to being responsive and helpful to SIGPR,” Laurie Schaffer wrote in an April 27 letter to Miller.

Because of the OLC’s determination, Miller said, his office will have to “discontinue many ongoing oversight efforts and transfer others, including criminal investigations and leads.”

“SIGPR’s jurisdiction has come to be viewed narrowly, not expansively, and my only conclusion is that ‘things are not working well,’ ” he said.

Miller called on lawmakers to pass legislation to “clarify” his office’s mandate to provide oversight of the Treasury’s pandemic-related programs.

The $2.2 trillion stimulus package, the CARES Act, last year created several overlapping oversight entities, including the Special Inspector General for Pandemic Recovery within the Treasury Department, to keep tabs on spending.

The special inspector general was tasked with auditing and investigating the loans, loan guarantees and other investments made by the Treasury secretary for some of the stimulus bill’s programs.

The legislation also instructs the special inspector general to provide quarterly reports to Congress summarizing its activities and an up-to-date accounting of the loans and other transactions.

Miller, a former lawyer in the Trump White House counsel’s office, was tapped by then-President Donald Trump for the role, prompting sharp criticism from Democrats. He was confirmed by the Senate last June on a 51-40 vote, with then-Sen. Doug Jones as the only Democrat to support his nomination.

Miller also previously served as General Services Administration inspector general during the Bush and Obama administrations.

This story has been updated with additional details Saturday.

Coronavirus / National Politics / News

CNN Newsource



  1. Gee golly. You mean the trillions of printed dollars given to everything but covid response won’t be accounted for? How can that be with Joe Biden, who so successfully oversaw Obama’s stimulus can get to the bottom of this.

    1. The article is about the funds from the Cares Act which was passed in March 2020 under the dictator wannabe. Those funds found their way into pockets and bank accounts long before Biden won the election, so any misdirection of dollars, if discovered, would have been under the purview of one of Trump’s minions. If you’re going to blame Biden for something, at least make sure it’s something he could have been responsible for.

      1. Let’s see which Red and Blue states get this right. My daughter lives in Oregon. My son lives in Washington. The two most *’d up states when it comes to closures and unemployment relief. I’m pretty sure Inslee got a D in government, and Brown got an F. Thank God for both of them that 85 percent of the dumbest people in the US live in the PNW.

        1. What I THINK doesn’t matter. Only evidence does. Do you have any proof of malfeasance by the Biden administration? Without proof, your suggestion of wrongdoing that MIGHT happen has about as much substance as Jewish lasers from space.

  2. Hi joe-bidens-nose. TeeHeeHee! Looks like you are not one of the WOKE crowd but instead an intelligent, common sense observer of how the Democrats keep ripping off ALL Americans. Not JUST the “stupid, redneck, uneducated Republicans and Conservatives”, but EVERY TAX PAYING person throughout the US for their own power and pockets. I used to think most people would WAKE UP and see through the horrible corruption and lies of the Democrats, like blaming Republicans for starting the KKK, for instance. Oh well. Those of us who SEE what has been going on for generations and look back into history and realize how America is presently being destroyed, as other free countries have been in the past, are not being listened to.

    1. An attempted insurrection preserves free countries? Overturning the results of an election protects democracy how? Talk about the need to WAKE UP!

  3. You all crack me up when you call it an insurrection!

    Criminal behavior, yes. They should all be arrested and prosecuted for sure.

    Stupid angry mob for sure! But, insurrection? When they got to Nancy’s chair they sat there and took selfies.

    What got little media attention is the police officer that smoked that girl for trespassing.

    Black cop, white girl, no charges.

Leave a Reply

Skip to content