Jury hears closing arguments in trial of White woman who fatally shot Black neighbor amid dispute over kids playing outside

(CNN) — Jurors heard closing arguments Friday in the trial of a White woman accused of fatally shooting an unarmed Black mother during an ongoing dispute over children playing near her home.

The panel also received instructions from the judge before deliberating whether Susan Lorincz was justified under the state’s controversial self-defense laws when she fired through the front door of her central Florida apartment last June and killed 35-year-old Ajike “AJ” Owens, who had been knocking on Lorincz’s door.

Lorincz, 60, is charged with manslaughter with a firearm and has pleaded not guilty. She faces up to 30 years in prison if convicted, according to State Attorney Bill Gladson’s office.

In his closing argument, prosecutor Rich Buxman told jurors Lorincz admitted pulling the trigger and killing Owens.

“It wasn’t an accidental situation. It wasn’t a situation where she slipped and the gun accidentally went off and shot the door and struck Ms. Owens,” Buxman said. “That’s not what we have here. She intentionally fired it. There’s no doubt that the defendant intentionally committed an act, which caused the death of Ajike Owens.”

Buxman said Lorincz acted with “utter disregard for the life of others.”

“She pointed a loaded firearm towards a door, towards a person that she knew was there in the opposite side of the door and intentionally pulled the trigger. That shows a reckless disregard for human life,” he told jurors.

In her closing argument, defense attorney Amanda Sizemore told jurors the case is one of perception.

“The constitution of our country embodies the right to be able to defend ourselves,” said Sizemore, whose remarks followed the prosecution’s closing argument. “The law demands that we assess the reasonableness of that perception, not from the comfort of a courtroom, but we have to take ourselves back to the perspective of the moment itself.”

Under Florida law, Sizemore said, citizens have the right to defend themselves in the face of imminent danger. “She has no duty to retreat, and she can stand her ground when she is in her dwelling if she is faced with imminent danger,” she said of Lorincz.

Sizemore described Lorincz as an older woman with medical issues who lived alone in a troubled neighborhood when one night she was “startled by a barrage of screaming, profanities and banging on her door.”

“In that circumstance, it’s what Susan Lorincz reasonably believed was necessary to prevent – that’s a very important word, prevent. The law does not say that you have to wait to get punched or attacked before you can do something. You can use deadly force to prevent someone from coming into your home and hurting you or attacking you,” Sizemore said.

While the defense has maintained Lorincz had “no choice” but to shoot, Buxman countered that line of reasoning Friday morning, saying in order for the defendant to lawfully use deadly force, the threat to her life “must be imminent.”

“It had to be ready to happen. It had to be staring her in the face such as she had to act at that moment to protect her life,” the prosecutor said in his closing remarks.

“If Ms. Owens would somehow have managed to bust through this locked, dead bolted metal door, enter her house and start coming at her, the defendant may have had a right to shoot … but that’s not the situation we have here.”

Lorincz’s attorney has argued that she feared Owens would harm her and believed she had “no choice” but to shoot.

On Thursday, Lorincz told the court that, after consulting her attorneys, she had decided not to testify. The defense rested after calling expert witnesses on ballistics and police training who testified about where Lorincz was standing when she opened fire and her state of mind at the time of the shooting.

A day earlier jurors heard testimony from Marion County Sheriff’s Detective Ryan Stith, the lead investigator in the case. Prosecutors asked Stith to read a letter Lorincz reportedly wrote to Owens’ four children after he informed her she would be charged in Owens’ death.

“I am so, so sorry for your loss,” Stith read to the court. “I never meant to kill your mother. I was terrified your mom was going to kill me. I shot out of fear.”

Outside the courthouse, Owens’ mother, Pamala Dias, told reporters she struggled to maintain her composure throughout the trial.

“‘Difficult’ is putting it very mildly,” Dias said. “The amount of emotions, the disgust, the anguish, the pain – to sit there literally feet away from the woman who took my daughter’s life … I have to dig deep within my strength, my faith to hold it all together.”

In the video of her first interrogation, shown to jurors Wednesday, Lorincz tells detectives she’d previously argued with Owens about her children playing loudly and leaving toys outside her home. But she tells police the situation escalated on June 2, 2023, after she confronted the children about the noise and threw their roller skates.

Lorincz tells detectives she called the police that evening to report that neighborhood children had threatened to kill her. She says dispatchers told her to lock her door and that officers were on the way.

But before police could arrive, Lorincz tells detectives, Owens began “banging on my door” and saying, “I’m going to kill you.”   

“She bangs so hard it looked like my door was going to fly off,” Lorincz said in the video. “And I just, I panicked and I was like, ‘Oh my god, she’s really going to kill me this time.’ You know? And so, I don’t even remember picking the gun up, I just remember shooting.”

The-CNN-Wire
™ & © 2024 Cable News Network, Inc., a Warner Bros. Discovery Company. All rights reserved.