Skip to Content

Fact check: False claims that DC requires photo ID or proof of vaccination to buy milk or leave your home

<i>Ting Shen/Xinhua News Agency/Getty Images</i><br/>The claims that DC requires photo ID or proof of vaccination to buy milk or leave your home are false.
Xinhua News Agency via Getty Ima
Ting Shen/Xinhua News Agency/Getty Images
The claims that DC requires photo ID or proof of vaccination to buy milk or leave your home are false.

By Daniel Dale

Last week, some Republican lawmakers wrongly described Washington DC’s new proof-of-vaccination policy — incorrectly tweeting that the Democratic-run city is requiring people to show photo identification to buy milk or even to leave their homes.

Their inaccurate tweets, however, came after Democratic Mayor Muriel Bowser herself used overly broad language in a tweet describing the policy. Bowser’s tweet could have led the senators and others astray, though the senators could certainly have verified the details before posting.

Bowser tweeted on Tuesday that starting Saturday, people age 18 and older would need three things “before heading out”: a mask, proof of vaccination and photo ID. (She wrote that people ages 12 through 17 would need the mask and proof of vaccination but not the photo ID.) The tweet concluded by saying people could get more information by clicking her link to a government website.

Two Republican senators amplified Bowser’s tweet in their own tweets. If they had clicked the link to get more information, however, they did not show it.

Sen. Marsha Blackburn of Tennessee said in a Wednesday tweet: “Liberal logic: you need a photo ID to buy milk but not to vote.”

Sen. Ron Johnson of Wisconsin said in a Tuesday tweet: “Dems think it’s racist to require voter ID but are happy to segregate the unvaxxed and require anyone leaving their home to have a photo ID, mask, and proof of vaccine.”

Facts First: Washington is not requiring photo ID or proof of Covid-19 vaccination from everyone leaving their home or from people buying groceries like milk. The new policy exempts grocery stores and other retail establishments, and it does not apply to people who are merely venturing outside their homes.

Rather, the policy requires people age 18 or older to show photo ID and proof of vaccination when entering certain indoor establishments: restaurants, bars, food halls and food courts, nightclubs, breweries, entertainment venues, exercise facilities and meeting facilities. (The policy says that people who are entering even these establishments for certain brief stops — to use a restroom, to pay, to pick up or place an order, or to get to an outdoor area — are not required to show proof of vaccination, but they must still wear masks while inside.)

It’s not hard to find the list of places covered by the policy: it is visible to anyone who visits the page to which Bowser tweeted a link. And clicking a link that is prominently featured on that page, in turn, brings up a document with even more details — such as the fact that grocery stores are exempt. (Someone who wanted to get milk at a non-exempt establishment like a restaurant or food court would have to show ID first, but Blackburn tweeted a much broader suggestion that people would generally need ID to buy milk in the city.)

The proof-of-vaccination policy commenced at 6 a.m., local time, on Saturday by requiring proof that someone has received one dose of a Covid-19 vaccine. Beginning on February 15, that will change to requiring proof that someone has received two doses of an mRNA vaccine like Pfizer’s and Moderna’s or one dose of the Johnson & Johnson vaccine. From Saturday onward, people with medical or religious exemptions from vaccination must instead show proof of a negative test within the last 24 hours and documentation confirming the exemption.

Some other big Democratic-run cities, such as New York City, Los Angeles, Chicago, Philadelphia and Boston, also require evidence of vaccination from people entering restaurants, bars and some other venues. But none of these big cities requires proof of vaccination merely to leave one’s home or to shop at a grocery store.

Spokespeople for Johnson and Bowser did not respond to requests for comment. Blackburn’s office declined to comment.

The-CNN-Wire
™ & © 2022 Cable News Network, Inc., a WarnerMedia Company. All rights reserved.

CNN Newsource

Comments

13 Comments

    1. Trump looks will believe anything and do anything big fat failed and fired donnie the orange snowflake tells them to!!!! ROTFLMAO!!! Soooooo much losing for the trump Borg!!! Little tucker girlson reporting that his buddy Glenn bleck the cocaine addicted alcoholic told him that there are internment camps in Washington state for the unvaccinated!!!! Toooooo funny!!! Ignorance and conspiracy theories = “freedom” for the failed trump Borg!!!

  1. so the dem mayor tweeted out a rule that others then commented on, yet the “fact checkers” lambaste the others rather than the mayor herself?

    interesting approach from the MSUN (Make **** Up Network) – formerly known as CNN.

      1. Stating a fact without mentioning critical information about said fact that gives people the wrong impression is a falsehood by omission that CNN does ALL the time that I have pointed out numerous times.

        1. Ah yes, “whataboutism” by any other name still is no proof of false claims they “lie” or “make stuff up.” Every reporter, every editor makes decisions on what’s worth including or not including in a story. That’s called responsible journalism. Stories that refute or don’t back your opinions or biases aren’t “lies.”

          1. That is one of the dumbest things I’ve ever read from you Barney. An incomplete truth/fact is still essentially a lie. And “responsible journalism” is giving the people the complete truth/fact, not a partial truth/fact. Your way of thinking is partly why journalism is dead.

            1. And I could argue the same about your way of thinking. Since journalism began, folks have “read between the lines” things the reporter has no control over. “Complete truth”? There’s a readers’ judgment call, to be sure. “Incomplete truth”? Wow, that’s a spin.

  2. Fact check: KTVZ is just as bad as cnn (communist news network). I know ktvz doesn’t have the financial support to break away from cnn but they can renegotiate there contract or maybe they do have the money. This is why Barney you have posters come on here, is to call ktvz lying liberal news clips out. I actually like getting my actual news from the Westside media more then this so-called news media outlet but I come on here to moderate your so called news articles.

    1. Our company won’t be moving away from CNN Wire – no other network offers anything similar to affiliates.
      And anyone who points out actual errors in CNN content, we check and pass it along.
      Instead, it’s an over-generalized trashing of content, with false claims of “lying.” Then comes “lying by omission,” which is “whatabout-ism.” Some of their stories have a spin we don’t like but the vast majority are factual and quote folks from both/all sides, if they are available/willing to talk.

Leave a Reply

Skip to content